Coming Out of the Closet: Why Female Gamers Don’t Talk Game
A gender divide has long been prevalent in gaming subculture. The majority of playable character heroes are male. Gaming advertisements are largely male. And as if this wasn’t enough to deter the average female away from gaming – men repeatedly scold women for their inability to play games and play them well (even though most men have had ten or fifteen years to suck at games before improvement). In simplest terms, gaming is the man’s “man world.”
The paradox of this male driven market is that so many men, especially boyfriends, fiancés, and spouses want their female counterparts to play with them – if for no other reason than males want to make sure they aren’t stepping on anyone’s toes when they play Halo 3 for seven hours straight. I’ve read dozens of blogs by men who are trying to achieve this feat and while it obviously behooves men to share this obsession, a female has to wonder, to what extent are men willing to share?
Do you really want your girlfriend to be better at playing video games than you are? Would it make you feel like less and less of a man if suddenly the industry was wracked with more female gamers than male (perhaps a 70-30 split)? What if nearly every epic video game you turned on you were forced to play as a woman with no option to play as a man? What if nearly every staffer at Gamespot was a woman instead of a man and we could hear male jokes instead of female jokes throughout each Hot Spot broadcast? As a subculture even Gamespot doesn’t necessarily take female gamers seriously. We’re generally a mockery – a fictional unicorn of sorts, a breed so rare that most men generally forget that we exist. Of course, we’re not really that rare, we’re just illusive. The Entertainment Software Association cites that, “Thirty-eight percent of game players are women” (http://www.theesa.com/facts/gamer_data.php). Thirty-eight percent? And yet, it would seem to be quite less, wouldn’t it?
And then, men wonder, well where are these women and why don’t more women want to play games? Why don’t they understand the hobby? I live on the cultural divide, a chasm of sorts. I say this because I have obviously adapted to this man’s hobby. I practically live, breathe, and eat video games every day. I have a nice little niche of people I can discuss games with. And more often than not, I don’t really care that every person I talk to about games is a man. What I am trying to do is address a complaint that men often have about women – that they suck at video games and show no interest. On the contrary, there are countless women that play video games and simply choose not to tell male gamers about it. I know of at least three female friends that do not tell their boyfriends that they play video games. They don’t want to be teased about it. They don’t want to be questioned as to why they enjoyed Bioshock better than Barbie’s Castle of Polluted Ideals. They don’t want you to know that they are actively participating in a hobby which is largely considered unfeminine. Sad isn’t it? So many men want gamer girlfriends and here they are, right under everyone’s nose. Perhaps these three people make up part of our illusive “thirty-eight percent” demographic. On the subject of games…
What few attempts have been made to incorporate women into this subculture have been both shallow and miserable. Does anyone else remember the Dream Skin Care trailer that Gamespot played for the Tokyo Game Show? I nearly died with laughter when the camera cut back to the faces of the Hot Spot staff, who were wearing blank expressions of shock. Do men think that women really want to play this type of game? Don’t get me wrong, I am well aware that Gamespot’s take on the Dream Skin Care DS game is comic genius. But I think the simple fact that this game was made says an awful lot about the state of the video game industry and what developer’s think women want to play. I may be a woman, but I want absolutely nothing to do with this Dream Skin Care game or any of the thousand other shallow, half-hearted attempts at female oriented game-play.









Comment by Erik Steffl on 10 March 2008:
“The majority of playable character heroes are male.” - is that still true? A (female) friend of mine came to realization I play games for the hot female lead characters when I was pointing out which games I played/liked at Fry’s (thought never occured to me).
As far as taking female gamers seriously - that’s not likely to happen anytime soon. Not because they are female but simply because males are competitive/aggressive and will taunt and make fun and try to beat anybody, male or female. Testosterone
What you describe as negative attitude towards females is just general attitude
Sometime it’s more visible in female version cause they can be singled out.
btw from what I can tell there are very few grownup women that play computer/video games however upcoming generation (kids/teens) of females seem to be much more comfortable with computers in general and play games more often.
“What few attempts have been made to incorporate women into this subculture have been both shallow and miserable.” … “Do men think that women really want to play this type of game?” … “And while you may personally give the female gamer your time and interest, by and large this industry does not.” - I don’t think it’s the question of industry as an impersonal monster. If more females go and make games then games will be more like what females want (if females indeed want different games than what males want, I can’t speak for females). So don’t go blame industry, go and make games
ero
Comment by Tasha Ward on 10 March 2008:
Erik,
Niiiiice. So would you be the Lara Croft type?
Actually, there are a great number of adult women that play video games. Although, I believe that in general they play online party games like Slingo and Family Feud. To me, that hardly constitutes as a video game.
BTW, I’d love to be a game developer, but alas, I have none of the skills needed to be a game developer. Once upon a time I thought I could write dialog for characters. Some video games seem to be suffering from horrendous scripting. Two Worlds anyone?
Pingback by Your Studio Blog» Blog Archive » Women Gamers And Game Creators on 10 March 2008:
[…] on female gamers. In the first one, CNN looks at the push to get more women designing games. The second article on Worldwideweb.net talks about the divide between men and women in the video gaming world and why […]